-  [WT]  [Home] [Manage]

[Return] [Entire Thread] [Last 50 posts]
Posting mode: Reply
Subject   (reply to 103213)
File URL
Embed   Help
Password  (for post and file deletion)
  • Supported file types are: GIF, JPG, PNG, WEBM
  • Maximum file size allowed is 5120 KB.
  • Images greater than 300x300 pixels will be thumbnailed.
  • Currently 1114 unique user posts. View catalog

  • Blotter updated: 2017-02-04 Show/Hide Show All

Patches and Stickers for sale here

File 149046004336.png - (357.18KB , 2000x600 , Benelli-m3-tactical-12.png )
103213 No. 103213 ID: 813f6b
I'm filled with the need to fill a void in my collection (and life): I want a high quality shotgun.

This quest started with trying to find (or make) a suitable classic looking Ithaca 37 (either already SBS, or make it into one). That didn't go anywhere. Ithaca doesn't export to euroland, and I'm having trouble finding a suitable donor gun to SBS (or even to find someone willing to SBS the gun for me since due to regulations it has to be reproofed etc, meaning paperwork & wasted time going to the test bench/proof house which would cost more than the actual cutting & refinishing).

Other alternatives were visited:
Browning has an Ithaca sibling, so that was the first stop. Various features and components were not really to my liking though, missing that special M37 look.
Mossbergs have a handy lefty friendly safety, so I looked at those next. Turns out their finish is really shitty.
Remingtons, well, let's not even go there. I've seen too many Remington things fail in the past 10 years that I'm not willing to touch them anymore.
Winchester was next. SXP is a basic no nonsense shotty made in Turkey, but turns out it's actually has more than it's share of problems if jewtoob is to be believed. Including at least two instances of slamfiring with the safety on. So that's out.

With time, interests shifted and eventually brought me to the Benelli M3 Tactical (~20", ghost ring sights, classic stock) & Benelli M3 Entry (~14", ghost ring sights, usually telescopic stock). Because why the fuck not? It's both a pump and a semi, filling two needs at once.
Expand all images
>> No. 103214 ID: 813f6b
File 149046043450.jpg - (91.87KB , 1494x396 , Benelli_M3_Entry_new.jpg )
I'm quite split on the choice between a 18.5" to 20" Tactical and the 14" Entry. I do know I kinda prefer the classic stock instead, so I'd go that way for both choices. 14" seems super handy and is more than sufficient for me since I intend to use it for some fun gunning, not any other specific use.

But turns out that the Benelli M3 Tactical is still produced, but the Entry isn't. Luckily there's some second hand ones for sale and I've already tracked down a NIB in a store in France.

So what do you guys think about both choices? 14" seems to be more fun to play around with and brings the weight down a tiny bit, but the 20" will be a lot easier to get and also cheaper.
>> No. 103216 ID: 813f6b
File 149046146688.jpg - (40.98KB , 1000x1000 , BenelliM3Entry-n1-01_44_96.jpg )
The telescopic stock seems highly sought after in the US etc, but I don't see the appeal (other than being easier to adjust when wearing a thick tac vest, since Benelli LOP is kinda long).
>> No. 103219 ID: f2172d
Not a huge fan of the benelli stock myself.

Have you thought about a FN SLP? I like 'em.
>> No. 103241 ID: 813f6b
File 149051593287.jpg - (14.08KB , 481x185 , benelli_m3_switch.jpg )
>Have you thought about a FN SLP? I like 'em.

The aim is to get a pump (for fun, not an actual practical reason). Being semi as well is just gravy.
>> No. 103242 ID: 9dcda2
Pump-automatic guns are pretty satisfying, unless it's a Benelli Nova, they're shitty. The two downsides to pump guns are (1) Having to pump it and (2) No recoil reduction. Not ideal for competition, hunting, or slaying bodies, but I don't think that matters to you.

Let me see if I understand the criteria here:

1. Shotgun
2. Fucking awesome
3. High quality
4. US firearms laws need not apply
5. Pump action

The Benelli M3 is probably the best gun and most practical.

The SPAS-12 is legendary in coolness, but is a heavy bitch.
>> No. 103243 ID: 9dcda2
File 149053797819.jpg - (288.84KB , 1600x1200 , mg0809.jpg )
Maybe a Winchester 1897 Trench Gun? I'd skip the Chinese one and try to find an original.

This is probably the next gun on my list to get.

Photo from our old friend, DrakeGmbH.
>> No. 103244 ID: 9dcda2
File 149053834836.jpg - (0.97MB , 2938x1652 , v0dwI7g.jpg )
The Remington 870 is a good gun***. I've got a ~2008 production gun that's good to go.

*** It's heavy and outdated. It was designed in the late 1940s.

The 1960-1980 production "Wingmasters" are nice guns. (I'd do some research on the dates there.) The deep bluing is beautiful.

The "Police" guns are also good to go.
>> No. 103245 ID: 9dcda2
  I know WarPlanRed is going to hate me for this, but I really don't like Mossbergs. I'm not impressed by the 500 or 590. They cycle like there is gravel in the receiver.

I've seen multiple 930 JM Pros turn into "Jam Pros". The regular 930's seem to run ok.
>> No. 103246 ID: 9dcda2
File 149053912529.jpg - (163.06KB , 1600x577 , rem870destroyer.jpg )
Here's my 870, with side saddle and face melting Streamlight TLR-1HP. (Which has now moved to the SCAR 16 for night shoots.)

I shot one sporting clays event (150 rounds) with the 870 and immediately bought a semi-auto gun.
>> No. 103247 ID: 9dcda2
File 149053925590.jpg - (139.85KB , 1200x1323 , bird guns_2.jpg )
The 870 with the original 26" barrel and the semi I bought, the Beretta AL391. I got the 391 for ~$800, it was a steal. The previous owner put a box of shells through it and decided he didn't like it.
>> No. 103248 ID: 9dcda2
  The Beretta AL391 shooting sporting clays.

> Yeah full choke!

The video is pretty useless since you can't see the clays, but at least you can see the gun cycle.
>> No. 103249 ID: 813f6b
File 149054709892.jpg - (31.05KB , 600x600 , BenelliM3super90Tactical.jpg )
I've tracked down two NIB Entry models in France, which I can import. But they'll easily cost as much as a Tactical + a Rem870 on top. And I'll likely to spend a bit of extra to buy the classic stock since it comes with the telescopic stock.
On the other hand, if I just get the 20" Tactical, I kinda feel I might regret it long term... Always wondering if the 14" wouldn't be handier/cooler/more unique.

>The Benelli M3 is probably the best gun and most practical.

Well, since you mention recoil in your post, the M3 is rather shitty at sucking up recoil in semi mode. Still kicks hard. Harder than pure semi shotties.

>Maybe a Winchester 1897 Trench Gun? I'd skip the Chinese one and try to find an original.

An original good condition one costs more than a brand new M3 Tactical though. Maybe as much as an M3 Entry.

While I love sword bayonets and slam firing as much as the next guy, this is a bit much.

>I know WarPlanRed is going to hate me for this, but I really don't like Mossbergs. I'm not impressed by the 500 or 590. They cycle like there is gravel in the receiver.

Yeah, I've got a feeling that the 500/590 are just cheap work horses of the "good enough" kind. I'd prefer something more refined.
>> No. 103250 ID: 19518e
>WarPlanRed is going to hate me for this, but I really don't like Mossbergs. I'm not impressed by the 500 or 590. They cycle like there is gravel in the receiver.
I had to polish mine a bit to be smooth, and the 590A1s with the thick barrels are super heavy. I tend to recommend old 870 Wingmasters, they can be found for $300 and they're by far the best built, smoothest, and nicest pumps for the money.

Might sell the 590 actually, now that I have a Wingmaster with a long barrel and a 12" barrel, I'm not sure I really have any purpose for the Mossberg. That or sell/trade it for a 535 3-in-1 combo, they're cheap, they shoot 3.5" shells, and come with everything you'd need to hunt any game with a shotgun. My 590A1 has been sitting around for a while, it's fun to take out sometimes because of the sights and how beast it feels, the pump stroke still makes me smile. Mossbergs, once polished, have the most distinct mechanical feel to them. It's like no other shotgun, and the sequence of smooth clicks and shlacks you get from pumping a 5** is just Adeptus Mechanicus bonerfuel. For that reason alone, I will probably always own a Mossberg.

>Yeah, I've got a feeling that the 500/590 are just cheap work horses of the "good enough" kind. I'd prefer something more refined.
With a bit of work they're good, but my feelings for them have definitely cooled since my experience with 870 Wingmasters. Aside from the aforementioned pump feel.

>I shot one sporting clays event (150 rounds) with the 870 and immediately bought a semi-auto gun.
This might be a downside to some, but I see it as an upside; the older Wingmasters are in 2 3/4" only. That does restrict your versatility a bit, but the upside is the pump stroke is shorter than pretty much any other production 12 gauge out there. It's fucking fast when you start getting the hang of cycling a 2 3/4" only action.

Definitely a plus if you're buying a pump that you never have the intention of using for anything that would require longer shells than 2 3/4".
>> No. 103251 ID: 9dcda2
File 149055523150.jpg - (212.14KB , 536x792 , dueling_tree_ar500.jpg )
> 2 3/4" shells ... 3.5" shells

Everything is a tradeoff.

2 3/4" shells - Standard 12ga length. Can kill anything on the planet with the right load. Fast cycling, lots of ammo availability.

3" shells - For when you want to fuck with your friends: Slip a 3" turkey load into the tube.

3 1/2" shells - Replacement for 10ga. Mostly used for bird genocide and dislocating shoulders.

We had a dueling tree set up at the last 3 gun. One dude brought out his bird gun. Only 2 in the mag tube, but whatever. Every time he hit the tree, it would shudder and flip the 3 (required) targets around. Damn. Ok those targets are neutralized.

We inspected his ammo: 7 1/2 birdshot (ok) and 3 1/2 inch shells. (ohhhh)
>> No. 103252 ID: 19518e
Indeed. I wanted to point it out because I haven't often seen people mention that when discussing one pump shotgun over another when the purpose of the gun is specified.

>3 1/2"
I particularly like the 3 1/2" turkey loads. Kent, Federal, and Winchester amongst others make the 2 1/4 ounce at 1150 to 1250ft/s from those shells. These days I've been shooting quite a bit of the Kent Diamond 2 1/4 ounce from my buddy's 870 Supermag.

I tell ya it's a wild ride, but cycling that action is like left-hand jab practice.
>> No. 103253 ID: b70c98
File 149057670093.jpg - (3.72MB , 2448x2448 , 20170320_110628.jpg )
Muh mids 70's wingmaster.
>> No. 103254 ID: b70c98
File 149057675072.jpg - (3.45MB , 2448x2448 , 20170320_110723.jpg )
>> No. 103255 ID: b70c98
File 149057677579.jpg - (3.48MB , 2448x2448 , 20170320_112413.jpg )
>> No. 103256 ID: b70c98
File 149057682444.jpg - (3.40MB , 2448x2448 , 20170320_113032.jpg )
>> No. 103260 ID: 813f6b
File 149063557669.png - (315.29KB , 1800x516 , Benelli-M3-A1-14inc-chiuso.png )
Turns out that Benelli DEFENSE does still sell the Entry model (calling it the M3 A1 14" and 14.5" Door-Breacher), but not Benelli civilian? Guess I'll need to contact some police suppliers...
>> No. 103275 ID: 0f04c4
My advice is to go with your gut. If you think there is even the most remote chance you'll regret the 20", laws of pessimistic living state you will. Even if it's harder to procure, the 14" seems to me to be what you really want. So pursue that Great White Buffalo. Overcoming the challenge of acquiring it will only make it that much more special to you.
>> No. 103286 ID: 6abc78
From experience I say the Mossy 930 can be damn good. Mine was shit out of box, and I mean complete jammomatic junk. The shotguns bolt and carrier need to be sanded smooth, and the recoil spring needs its ends smoothed out. My 930 needed the extractor spring snipped and weakened to function right. Now this gun runs the lightest, cheapest shot with no hiccups. It doesn't have the versatility of a M3, but it's 1/3 of the price.
>> No. 103321 ID: 6ef9f1
How hard would it be to get your hands on an older Auto 5?

They're super well made and I got mine for around 350$ after tax and transfer in CA.
>> No. 103323 ID: 813f6b
File 149089322535.png - (2.63KB , 168x141 , 132603849158.png )
I wonder why people keep suggesting semi auto shotguns when I clearly primarily aim to get a pump?
>> No. 103324 ID: b52eac
Auto shotty Master race?
>> No. 103325 ID: 6057a8
How much autoscatter have you shot?

Because I caught the bug pretty quick. Pumps are definitely cool, but autos are just so damn fun.
>> No. 103327 ID: 044fd0
Ithaca Stakeout is pretty to look at, but not so pretty to shoot. Slightly better with the buttstock than with the pistol grip but still not pleasant. Would help if I could put a modern stock on it but the older Ithacas like mine have a longer stock tang than the newer ones.

I've also owned both an older 870 Express and a Mossberg 500, I favor the Mossberg more because it's lighter and not so prone to rusting. The 870's weight is better at absorbing recoil though.
Have the hunting model Winchester 1200 with the 28 inch rib-ventilated, full-choke barrel. It strikes a good middle-ground between the 870 and 500 I think, and has slain many squirrels.
Also impulse-bought a Mossberg SA-20 a while back. It's alright for a Turkish gun though it doesn't reliably digest low-brass birdshot. To be expected though.

No pictures right now as I am on my other laptop.
>> No. 103331 ID: 813f6b
File 149098899438.png - (170.75KB , 400x300 , goodnewseveryone.png )
Good news everyone.

After constantly hounding the distributor & various stores, it turns out that the new Benelli M3 A1 14"/14.5" will be available in Belgium somewhere in May. It's practically the same price as the standard M3 Tactical even.

That means I need to get started on my permit application etc. Best case is 2 weeks, worst case is 4 months...

>How much autoscatter have you shot?

None that I can remember. Only pumps (rem870), O/U (Beretta & Browning) & SxS (don't remember) so far. And even only few of those.
>> No. 103333 ID: 19518e
Give it a go if you can, maybe before settling on a purchase.

There's not a whole lot quite like slinging half a pound of lead in two or three seconds just from pulling on one little trigger.
>> No. 103495 ID: 813f6b
>Good news everyone.

Bad news everyone. The store just contacted me to say Benelli changed their mind and that they won't be available in May and could not say if they would import it in the future or not.

Benelli M3 Tactical remains available though, so that question is if I should wait & keep pushing, or just settle for the full length Tactical.
>> No. 103503 ID: e9af5c

>buying m3 tactical

Gonna need you to pick one.
I know it not exactly what your heart desires, but damn. People would kill to afford a shotgun that nice.
>> No. 103505 ID: 19518e
Yeah I can just imagine Godvie all like "Damn they didn't have the Merkel model I wanted so I had to settle for the Blaser Luxus".
>> No. 103512 ID: 813f6b
File 149225190724.jpg - (42.22KB , 378x276 , 1286506467197.jpg )
Hey man, life is too short to settle for cheap shit.

I've grown to accept that I'm an elitist jerk. Aside from just high quality guns, I really appreciate overengineered and mechanically interesting guns.
Which is not to say that some cheap guns can't be great in their own right, obviously. I'm not that far gone...
>> No. 104958 ID: 8be205
don't know if you care, but benelli has stopped importing the m3 in all variations to the US, the m3's largest civilian sales market. M3 looks on the way out of production so stock up on parts now.
>> No. 104960 ID: bf333d
>don't know if you care, but benelli has stopped importing the m3 in all variations to the US, the m3's largest civilian sales market. M3 looks on the way out of production so stock up on parts now.

Considering Benelli Defense Italy just released the M3 A1 this year, I doubt it's going out of production in the EU. They also have too much law enforcement market to just stop providing spare parts.
>> No. 104961 ID: 413cfb
Winchester has always been my favorite shotgun brand. My dad has several pumps that are older than I am (30+ years) that run really nicely. I've taken a look at the guts of the SXP and it's pretty similar to the old 1300, just made with more modern techniques.

I'd suggest looking around for some old 1300 Speed Pump shotguns. They can be had for chump change.

If you gotta have NIB, which I totally understand, I'd suggest looking at the SXP again.
The issues were due to a production SNAFU in 2015, and limited to 3 1/2" Chambers. FWIW my buddy has an old 870 that was his father's first gun, and I've seen it fall over from resting against a tree, and fire with safety on.

If you're willing to spend Benelli money on a gun, then I'd look at the the FN P12 if you want the tacticool, next.

The P12 is around ~$700, the SXP Defender considerably cheaper at ~$450, in the US.

All that said, you do you. Just trying to help a brother out.
>> No. 105018 ID: 815268
I have a Vepr 12. It's pretty neat.
>> No. 105024 ID: bf333d
The point is moot by now, since I've already requested the permit for a Benelli M3. Can't use that permit for anything else.
>> No. 105719 ID: 241b9d
File 150817660890.jpg - (61.50KB , 411x337 , 1286122717463.jpg )
After months of promises, the Benelli importer for Belgium finally came clean and said my Benelli M3 Tactical won't be produced any time soon because the machines are all working full swing to produce more US Marine Corps M4s. And my permit expires on the 30th of November.

I'm mad.

So I'll need to get off my ass and import my own, pronto.

I've found several M3 Tacticals in Germoney, but if I need to import my own, I'm trying to track down the SBS version. Just because FUCK YOU, that's why.
I've found an SBS version in France, but it's way more expensive (like 500 bucks more expensive) and it's got the ugly collapsible stock like in >>103216 & >>103214 and I'd prefer the classic one like in >>103249. Buying a spare stock is like 100 bucks, but that's adding to an already more expensive shotgun.
>> No. 105723 ID: 241b9d
File 150824921710.jpg - (51.06KB , 422x347 , 1289778516074.jpg )
Store with the SBS version doesn't do export...
>> No. 105725 ID: 19518e
File 150827989919.gif - (700.31KB , 300x169 , 1392941798897.gif )
What a clusterfuck. You'd think those frogs would be accommodating with that price tag...
>> No. 105738 ID: 241b9d
File 15083265741.png - (113.05KB , 598x472 , 1294866322383.png )

It gets worse.

Through sheer desperation, I also contacted a local gunstore which is mostly focused on high price fudd hunting guns (Browning, Aya, Heym, Piotti, up to H&H and full custom guns). Turns out they just became Benelli importer.

The other guys which we were in contact with lost their import partnership with Benelli & that's why they can't deliver jack shit. So instead of being up front about that, they decided to just lie their fucking ass off?

I really don't know what to believe anymore, because Benelli hasn't updated their partner/dealer page yet.

But this is some seriously fucked up shit.
>> No. 105783 ID: 241b9d
File 15084044938.png - (520.95KB , 2000x704 , Benelli-m3-convertible-semi-auto-telescoping-stock.png )
Pic related should be in the next delivery to the local gun shop. So I'd need to swap the stock & it'd be good to go.
>> No. 105784 ID: 19518e
Shame it isn't an SBS but at least you found one.
>> No. 105786 ID: 241b9d
>Shame it isn't an SBS but at least you found one.

Well, if I'd ever decide to shoot matches, it would have needed to be one with a long mag tube anyway. It's less cute, but overall it's more practical.

Also, if I really still want an SBS one, I can just order the barrel next time I'm requesting some permits and modify the mag tube.
>> No. 105787 ID: 19518e
File 150852319272.jpg - (51.62KB , 691x469 , 1271781185143.jpg )
Oh that's good, I wasn't sure if you were allowed to get a shorter barrel and stuff. I have a hard enough time keeping up with canuck and US laws, eurobong laws are all bizarro land for me.
>> No. 105788 ID: 241b9d

Well, the permit needed for the barrel is the same as for the shotgun (meaning a significant amount of paperwork & wait times), so it's a bit of a pain, but I could combine it with future requests, so that'd be fine.
>> No. 105846 ID: 85f7d3
File 150924795629.png - (111.81KB , 1004x353 , m2-field-shotgun.png )
I don't mean to hijack your thread Godverdomme, and if you want me to start a new one just let me know, but I'm in a similar boat.

I've been shopping for a shotgun for a while now, and I don't know exactly what to get. My budget is flexible, but I'd like to stay under/around $1,200. I'm looking for something Semi-Auto, and I'd like to stay with inertia driven for the purposes of simplicity. As of right now, I'm looking at 2 main options:

Stoeger Family (M3000, M3K 3-Gun)
Benelli Family (Probably the M2 - but I don't know if I should look at the Montefeltro or Vinci instead).

The Stoeger would give me room to buy a pistol as well, which is a plus as I'm shopping for a new nightstand gun, but it seems like the Benelli is the nicer option with more aftermarket support. Primary use of the gun would be for Skeet/Trap, as well as Home Defense and potentially 3 gun further down the road. Any input would be appreciated.
>> No. 105847 ID: 241b9d
File 150928446358.jpg - (223.35KB , 1024x768 , shotties.jpg )
>I'd like to stay with inertia driven for the purposes of simplicity.

It's my understanding that this generates more perceived recoil though.
And it's not like the alternatives are especially complex.

>Primary use of the gun would be for Skeet/Trap, as well as Home Defense and potentially 3 gun further down the road.

My gut tells me that skeet/trap have quite different requirements than 3-gun, but I'm sure that someone with more experience in that can shed more light on it.
>> No. 105853 ID: 85f7d3

>My gut tells me that skeet/trap have quite different requirements than 3-gun, but I'm sure that someone with more experience in that can shed more light on it.

Yeah, basically I'm presuming that if I move on to 3-gun I'll get something else for trap and skeet like a Super Vinci or something. I know that the M2 and the M3000 can both become 3 gun shotguns through basic mods, but they can operate as trap/skeet guns immediately. Doe that make sense? It's why I'm not looking at a Vinci now; it can be a trap/skeet gun but it really doesn't have the aftermarket to support it as a 3 gun shotgun.

I also forgot to mention, but having the ability to get a Slug barrel would be nice as well. Here in Ohio most firearm deer hunting seems do be done with shotguns and the option would be good. Though it's a secondary concern, I could probably pick up a used 870 Police Magnum and get a slug barrel for not all that much.
>> No. 105864 ID: 241b9d

Plenty of slugs work fine without rifling though. So depending on what you aim for, a dedicated slug barrel may not be required.
>> No. 107223 ID: d408af
File 152364436964.jpg - (2.16MB , 5184x2912 , IMG_8988.jpg )
you do do you, man. I've slowly arrived here over the years.
Guns are expensive to replace, buy the ones that last.
>> No. 107232 ID: 0e1e77
File 152371373121.jpg - (43.06KB , 493x487 , bullets, shotgun slugs copper solid, Brenneke &.jpg )
Rifled lead slugs can be fired through regular smoothbore shotgun barrels, even ones with chokes, although improved cylinder works best. The rifling on these lead slugs imparts very little spin, but it allows these slugs to be swedged through any size normal choke. A rifled shotgun barrel allows you to shoot the more accurate sabot or copper-jacketed slugs.

Years ago, I bought a $200 Remington 850 pump and added a $90 Mossberg rifled shotgun barrel. Really unnecessary as I use cheap Brenneke slugs, but the barrel came with a length of rails that extends over the top of the lock that can fit sights to it. I put a cheap reflex sight on it and it works great at the 100 yard range that slugs are effective in. Other hunters love red dot scopes on their slug barrels.
[Return] [Entire Thread] [Last 50 posts]

Delete post []
Report post